The Heisman Trophy stands as the highest accolade in college football, awarded to the nation’s most outstanding player each year. Ohio State University has long been a powerhouse, producing top-tier talent, with Buckeyes players winning the Heisman seven times. However, in recent years, several Ohio State players delivered Heisman-worthy performances, only to fall just short of winning the coveted trophy. Here’s a look at four Buckeyes who were arguably robbed of the Heisman in recent years.
1. Chase Young (2019)
As a defensive end, Chase Young entered the Heisman conversation in a way that few defensive players ever do. Young dominated the 2019 season, recording 16.5 sacks and 21 tackles for loss, despite being suspended for two games. His relentless pursuit of quarterbacks and ability to disrupt offenses made him one of the most feared players in college football that year.
Young finished fourth in Heisman voting, an impressive feat for a defensive player, but many believe his impact on the field should have placed him even higher. While Joe Burrow’s historic season led him to win the Heisman decisively, Chase Young’s unmatched defensive prowess was arguably overlooked. Young went on to be the second overall pick in the 2020 NFL Draft, proving just how valuable he was on the field..
2. Justin Fields (2020)
Justin Fields was an electric presence at quarterback for the Buckeyes, showing poise, athleticism, and an ability to make big plays when it mattered most. In the shortened 2020 season, Fields threw for 2,100 yards and 22 touchdowns in just eight games, leading Ohio State to an undefeated regular season and the College Football Playoff National Championship game.
Despite these accomplishments, Fields finished seventh in Heisman voting. Many believe that if Fields had played a full season, his numbers would have rivaled those of winner DeVonta Smith. Fields’ performance in the semifinal against Clemson, where he threw six touchdown passes, showcased his Heisman potential. Yet, the unusual season format and the lack of games may have cost him his shot at the trophy.
3. C.J. Stroud (2021)
C.J. Stroud burst onto the scene as a redshirt freshman in 2021, throwing for over 4,400 yards, 44 touchdowns, and only six interceptions. Leading the Buckeyes’ offense with remarkable accuracy and poise, Stroud showcased his playmaking abilities throughout the season.
However, despite these impressive stats, Stroud finished fourth in Heisman voting. The 2021 Heisman ultimately went to Alabama’s Bryce Young, who delivered a standout season of his own. Nonetheless, Stroud’s numbers were comparable, if not better in some areas, and his contributions to Ohio State’s offense made him a top contender. Stroud’s placement in the Heisman voting was respectable, but many believe he deserved to finish higher.
4. Marvin Harrison Jr. (2022)
Marvin Harrison Jr. made a compelling case as one of the most talented wide receivers in college football during the 2022 season. His route-running, catch radius, and clutch performances made him an irreplaceable asset for the Buckeyes. Harrison recorded 77 receptions for 1,263 yards and 14 touchdowns, routinely making highlight-reel catches that showcased his elite skills.
However, Harrison Jr. didn’t even crack the top five in Heisman voting, a shock to fans and analysts alike. While wide receivers rarely win the Heisman, Harrison’s production and influence on Ohio State’s offense were undeniable. Many fans believe Harrison’s season was overshadowed by the award’s traditional focus on quarterbacks, yet his skill and contribution were as impactful as any of his contemporaries.
Each of these Buckeyes had a Heisman-worthy season, but various factors contributed to their near-misses. The Heisman voting system historically favors offensive players, particularly quarterbacks, which makes it difficult for defensive players or even standout wide receivers to gain the recognition they deserve. Additionally, in years where one player, like Joe Burrow in 2019, has a historic season, it’s tough for others, no matter how impactful, to stand out.
Ohio State’s status as a perennial powerhouse can also work against its players, as voters may focus on breakout players from less prominent programs. For example, Justin Fields faced stiff competition in a year when the number of games played was shortened, while Marvin Harrison Jr. was overshadowed by the 2022 Heisman competition’s heavy quarterback focus.
The Heisman Trophy has evaded Ohio State players in recent years, but it wasn’t for lack of talent or effort. Chase Young, Justin Fields, C.J. Stroud, and Marvin Harrison Jr. each left an undeniable mark on college football, delivering performances that any fan or analyst could consider Heisman-worthy. Although they didn’t take home the trophy, these Buckeyes’ accomplishments remain etched in Ohio State history and college football lore.
Looking forward, Ohio State will continue to produce standout players, and fans hope to see a Buckeye hoist the Heisman Trophy once again. Until then, these four players will be remembered as some of the most deserving Heisman contenders who just fell short.
Leave a Reply